On 3 July 1963, a National Airways Corporation DC-3 aircraft crashed during stormy weather on the Kaimai Range near Mount Ngatamahinerua when it was descending towards Tauranga. After searching was hampered by poor weather and the remoteness of the crash site, the wreckage of the plane was found on 5 July. All 20 passengers and the three crew aboard had lost their lives in what has been described as the worst air accident in NZ. A national memorial plaque was unveiled on the roadside near Gordon to mark the 40th Anniversary and a display opened at the Classic Flyers Museum at Mt Maunganui during the 60th Commemoration ceremony.
On 3 July 1963, 23 people lost their lives when their plane flying from Auckland to Tauranga crashed on the Kaimai Range
A national memorial plaque was unveiled on 40th Anniversary of what has been described as the worst air accident in NZ
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
What happened
On Wed 3 July at 8.21 am, the DC-3 flight NZ 441 had departed from Auckland's Whenuapai Airport for Tauranga Airport
There were 3 crew & 20 passengers aboard. (Another 3 passengers had changed their flight plans at the last minute.)
MOTAT
The DC-3 Skyliner ZK-AYZ had flown troops & weapons during WWII, & now flew for the National Airways Corporation (NAC)
Wairarapa Archive
Flight 441 was to stop in Tauranga, Gisborne, Napier & Palmerston North, before reaching Wellington in early afternoon
The three crew included: Pilot Len Enchmarch, First Officer Peter Kissel & Air hostess Elizabeth Wilson
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
At 9.06am, the Pilot contacted the Tauranga Airport Control Tower & gave an estimated arrival time of 9.08am
However, when the Control Tower tried to make contact at 9.14am & again at 9.16 am, there was no reply from the Pilot
Tauranga City Libraries
A worker at Gordon Quarry heard the plane overhead & the 'woof' sound of an impact at 9.09am, & phoned Matamata Police
The worker thought it unusual to have a passenger plane in the area. (The Quarry is halfway between Te Aroha & Matamata)
Tauranga City Libraries
The Matamata Police contacted Tauranga Airport at 9.20am & the plane was officially declared missing just after 9.30am
(The air traffic officer had kept calling the DC-3 from 9.21am to 10am, but without a reply.)
Tauranga City Libraries
The DC-3 had encountered stormy windy weather & drifted to the left as it approached the Kaimai Range
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
During a strong downdraught, the DC-3 had crashed onto a ridge near Mount Ngatamahinerua & burst into flames
Investigators later estimated the impact speed was from 140kmh to zero in roughly 3.5 metres
Tauranga City Libraries
Another plane flying from Hamilton across the Kaimai Range at 10am experienced severe downdraughts
The pilot reported the weather encountered to the Tauranga Control Tower & the Tauranga Airport was closed
Tauranga City Libraries
Rescue operations: Wed 3 July - Fri 5 July
Searchers set out from Gordon Quarry to begin looking for the plane on Wed 3 July
However, they turned back due to the weather & terrain, & reassembled the next day
Tauranga City Libraries
RNZ (3 July 1983): John Forster's report on the rescue operations at the Quarry's headquarters (8:03 mins)
Air crash near Matamata, 1963-07-03
Ngā Taonga Sound & Vision
Land search parties reformed at Gordon Quarry on Thurs 4 July
Volunteers & NZ Army soldiers began arriving to form search teams
Tauranga City Libraries
Aircraft wreckage, Gordon Quarry - Dr J Henderson
Tauranga City Libraries
Kaimai air disaster volunteers briefing, 1963
Tauranga City Libraries
Aircraft wreckage - Gordon Quarry
Tauranga City Libraries
Aircraft wreckage, Gordon Quarry - O J OBrien, Dr J Henderson and W Harvie
Tauranga City Libraries
Search and rescue volunteers arrive by tractor, 1963
Tauranga City Libraries
Search and rescue volunteers ascend into the Kaimais, 1963
Tauranga City Libraries
Searching for a missing aircraft
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
Kaimai air disaster search and rescue volunteers cross a river, 1963
Tauranga City Libraries
Kaimai air disaster search and rescue in-field radio operator, 1963
Tauranga City Libraries
Aerial searches were also carried out by an RNZAF Bristol Freighter & a private helicopter
Pilot Mike Alexander had loaded his Hiller 12E helicopter onto a trailer & travelled from Whanganui during the night
Tauranga City Libraries
At 11.58am, the Bristol Fighter crew found the plane's wreckage but survivors couldn't be spotted from the helicopter
(The helicopter was the first time that one had been used in a Search & Rescue operation in NZ)
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
The plane had struck a deep bush-clad rockface at an altitude of around 2460 ft (750m) at 140kmh & caught fire on impact
A map of the location of the plane crash is provided in the NZ History article "Kaimai air crash, 1963"
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
As the weather had deterioriated, the searchers returned to the Quarry headquarters for the night
Kaimai air disaster search and rescue volunteers 1963
Tauranga City Libraries
Search resumed on Fri 5 July for survivors
After the weather cleared, the search party journeyed by helicopter to resume looking for survivors
Tauranga City Libraries
The searchers dropped off by helicopter at the crash site found 22 people had died immediately & one later from exposure
Tauranga City Libraries
Recovery operations
Before the recovery of the bodies began, Ministers hovered above in a second helicopter to hold a brief Church service
The recovered bodies were taken to Te Aroha for identification
Tauranga City Libraries
Due to the remoteness of the crash, the wreckage was secured on site by the NZ Army
Drilling in prep for burying DC3 on Kaimai Ranges
Tauranga City Libraries
News of the crash & those who'd lost their lives was reported in the media, including Gisborne Photo News (8 Aug 1963)
Tragic Air Crash
Gisborne Photo News
Public enquiry held
A public enquiry ruled the accident to be a result of stormy weather conditions & poor navigation technology
It recommended aircraft carry locator beacons & distance-measuring equipment be installed at commercial airports
Archives New Zealand Te Rua Mahara o te Kāwanatanga
RNZ (3 July 1983): Interview with Wing Commander O'Brien, Inspector of Accidents, on his findings on the crash (1:22min)
Ngā Taonga Sound & Vision
In Nov 1963, the Kaimai Range was declared a 'mountainous terrain' & had to be flown over no less than 2000 feet
(Brief summary of findings & photo of the wreckage is provided in NZ History article, "DC-3 crashes in Kaimai Range")
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
Commemorations
40th Anniversary (2003)
A memorial cairn was dedicated on 3 July 2003 to mark the 40th anniversary
Thames Museum
The memorial is located on the Old Te Aroha Rd near Gordon, 4.3 km south-west of the crash site
P1250064
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
A photo of the memorial is included in NZHistory article, "Kaimai air crash memorial"
Kaimai air crash memorial
Manatū Taonga, the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
50th Anniversary (2013)
RNZ article with photos of the crashed aircraft & memorial plaque & audio (3:50 mins)
Radio New Zealand
RNZ interview (2013) with Dr Richard Waugh who wrote the book "Kaimai crash" in 2003 (10:21 min)
New Zealand's worst internal air disaster anniversary
Radio New Zealand
60th Anniversary (2023)
A memorial display with parts from the wreckage was unveiled at Classic Flyers Aviation Museum, Tauranga Airport in 2023
Air Force Museum of New Zealand
Find out more:
Alistair Bone (2 July 2013), "The Kaimai crash: 50 years on" (Stuff.co.nz)
Christchurch City Libraries: Kaimai Ranges plane crash. URL: https://my.christchurchcitylibraries.com/kaimai-ranges/
Luke Kirkness, (3 July 2023), "Remembering New Zealand’s worst domestic air accident: 60 years since the Kaimai tragedy", NZ Herald. (includes interview with one of the searchers who describes what he saw at the crash site.)
Natalie Akoorie (3 July 2023), "Kaimai crash: Disaster's scars still fresh after 50 years" (NZ Herald)
Roger Handford (4 July 2023), "Remembering the Kaimai Range air disaster: Six decades since NAC Flight 441 tragedy" (The Gisborne Herald)
Shania Callender (3 July 2023), "Kaimai air accident 60th Anniversary: Hundreds attend commemoration service", Bay of Plenty Times. (Also includes videotape (1:41 min) of Grant Horn who led the engine recovery mission.)
Wikipedia: New Zealand National Airways Corporation Flight 441
This DigitalNZ story was compiled in July 2024